Skip to main content
Five Star Placements

Legal recruiters in New York

Five Star Placements recruits attorneys, partners, in-house counsel, paralegals and legal staff for New York City law firms and legal departments, and across Westchester, Long Island, New Jersey and Connecticut. We speak with every candidate before you see them.

Who we place in New York

Our New York clients are mostly boutique and midsize firms in Manhattan and the Tri-State area, and companies hiring in-house counsel, including financial services and technology employers. Many candidates we present come from AmLaw offices, but we rarely place into those firms.

  • Associates and senior associates

    Litigation, corporate, finance and funds associates, screened for New York admission and the deal or matter experience you asked for.

  • Partners and of counsel

    Confidential partner and counsel searches, including counsel moving toward partnership and laterals bringing a practice with them.

  • In-house counsel

    General counsel, deputy GCs and specialist counsel for banks, asset managers, private equity sponsors, fintech and other companies in the New York area.

  • Paralegals

    Litigation, corporate and real estate paralegals for Manhattan firms and corporate legal departments.

  • Legal staff

    Legal assistants and legal secretaries for firms in Manhattan, Westchester, Long Island, New Jersey and Connecticut.

Practice areas we recruit for in New York

  • Commercial litigation

    Mid-level litigation associates hear from recruiters every week, so a clear pitch and a quick process decide who accepts.

  • Corporate and M&A

    Transactional associates and counsel for deal groups at boutiques and midsize firms, and for companies with in-house deal teams.

  • Private funds and private equity

    Funds associates with private equity deal experience are among the hardest New York profiles to find, and firms compete with sponsors for them.

  • Banking and finance

    Finance attorneys for firms and for the legal departments of banks, lenders and asset managers.

  • Regulatory and compliance

    Counsel with financial regulatory experience for banks, asset managers and fintech companies.

  • Employment and real estate

    Employment attorneys on both sides of the docket, and real estate transactional attorneys for Manhattan's property market.

What shapes a New York search

  • Multiple offers

    Strong mid-level candidates in New York often hold more than one offer, and signing bonuses are part of the competition. A slow interview process reads as low interest.

  • Confidential moves

    Partner and counsel moves are often handled quietly before they are announced. We write to each candidate individually rather than advertising the role.

  • In-house competition

    Banks, asset managers and fintech companies hire associates out of firms, so a firm's offer competes with in-house roles as well as with other firms.

  • Bar admission and office policy

    Most firm roles require New York admission, and New Jersey or Connecticut roles may require those bars. Candidates also filter roles by in-office requirements, so we confirm your policy before outreach.

How we run your search.

  1. A call about the role

    We spend thirty minutes with you on the practice, what you need in the hire, and how the search has gone so far.

    We start every search this way.

  2. Candidates

    We speak with each attorney before you see them and confirm they match what you asked for.

    The first candidate is sent within two weeks in 70% of searches.

  3. Interviews and feedback

    You tell us what's working. We adjust the search based on it.

    57% of submitted attorneys are invited to interview.

  4. Offer

    Before an offer goes out, we tell you what the candidate is likely to accept.

    Contingent fee, with nothing due until the attorney starts.

Based on our placement records since January 2025.

Fees

We work on a contingent fee. The hiring firm pays it, and nothing is due until the attorney starts. Attorneys we place never pay us. The fee and how it is calculated are agreed in writing before the search begins.

For how legal recruiting fees work in general, read legal recruiting fees explained and how much a legal recruiter costs.

Questions about hiring in New York

  • Do you recruit outside Manhattan?

    Yes. We recruit for law firms and legal departments in all five boroughs, Westchester, Long Island, northern New Jersey and Connecticut, and for remote roles based in the New York area.

  • Do you work with boutique firms or only large firms?

    Most of our New York clients are boutique and midsize firms, along with companies hiring in-house counsel. We often place attorneys coming from AmLaw firms, but we rarely place into them.

  • How much does a legal recruiter cost in New York?

    We work on a contingent fee: the hiring firm pays only when an attorney we presented starts, and nothing is due before then. The fee and how it is calculated are agreed in writing before the search begins. New York salaries are among the highest in the country, so a fee based on first-year compensation is larger in dollars than in most markets.

  • How quickly will we see candidates?

    In 70% of our searches, the first candidate is sent within two weeks (based on our placement records since January 2025). In New York, the time from first interview to accepted offer matters as much, because good candidates rarely have only one process running.

  • Can you run a confidential partner search?

    Yes. We approach candidates one at a time rather than advertising the role, and a candidate's name reaches you only after they have spoken with us and confirmed interest in your specific role.

Other cities

Hiring an attorney in New York?

Attorneys looking for a role can browse current openings or tell us what you are looking for.

Schedule a call